I have long been a fan of Patricia Highsmith’s “The Talented Mr. Ripley,” the first in a series about a con artist, with its fascinating premise and the unexpected twists and turns the novel takes. I find it a mesmerizing journey into the mind of the very sick Tom Ripley, a character as chilling as he is charming…sort of like someone I used to know.
What makes “The Talented Mr. Ripley” particularly compelling is its deep dive into the themes of homoeroticism, envy, and the human desire to be someone better. This psychological depth, combined with the book’s suspenseful plotting, ensures that Ripley’s story lingers on long after the final page is read and the book is closed.
Loving the book is the main reason I was initially attracted to the film by the same name. Directed by Anthony Minghella and starring Matt Damon, Jude Law, and Gwyneth Paltrow, the 1999 release offers a visually and emotionally engaging adaptation of the novel that isn’t what I’d classify as a “great film” but is one that I loved and still watch periodically, probably because I loved the novel as much as I did.
The film captures Italy's lush, seductive atmosphere with rich cinematography that enhances the story’s immersive quality. Matt Damon’s portrayal of Tom Ripley adeptly conveys the character’s awkward charm and underlying menace, aligning closely with the novel’s depiction of Ripley’s complex psychological landscape. Jude Law shines as the charismatic Dickie Greenleaf, embodying the carefree allure that Tom obsessively covets. At the same time, Gwyneth Paltrow’s Marge remains the emotionally wounded observer, much as she is in the book.
The following video is an enlightening interview by the film’s director:
The film does diverge from the book in that it emphasizes its more dramatic, cinematic quality…in a unique, stylized version that is difficult to describe. For instance, the relationships between the characters are more fleshed out, adding layers of romance and betrayal, which are not as explicitly present in the book. The film also alters some plot elements, shifting the focus slightly but retaining the core themes of identity, deception, and the dark sides of ambition. Minghella’s adaptation opts for a more overt expression of Tom’s inner conflicts and the consequences of his actions, which is subtler in Highsmith’s narrative. These adaptations allow the film to sand on its own as a compelling exploration of the consequences of envy and the extreme lengths one might go to in pursuit of someone else’s life while still honoring the spirit of the original novel.
Now, fast forward to the créme de la créme…”Ripley,” the Netflix series. This is one of the most captivating series I’ve ever seen. It revives the beguiling world of Tom Ripley, brilliantly acted by Andrew Scott, as represented in the Highsmith novel. Still, this character is much seedier than Tom Ripley, who Matt Damon plays in the film.
This rendition, directed by Steven Zaillian, brilliantly recaptures the icy charisma and cunning intellect, played with a chilling finesse that adds multiple layers to an already complex character. The series excels in its atmospheric tension, weaving a visual and narrative tapestry that transports viewers to the lush yet perilous landscapes of the ‘60s.
The studied pacing is deliberate, allowing the suspense to build naturally, while the sophisticated script keeps the dialogue sharp and engaging, making each episode a compelling piece. At the same time, the larger, intricate puzzle.
The aesthetic of this show is meticulously crafted, with each frame thoughtfully composed to echo the themes of deception and identity central to the Ripley saga.
The production design and costumes are period-perfect, enhancing the authenticity and immersive quality of the series. It is, in parts, mind-blowingly stunning, leaving me breathless at every turn. What sets this adaptation apart is its psychological depth; it dives deep into Ripley’s psyche, exploring his motivations and moral ambiguities in an unsettling and mesmerizing way. “Ripley” honors the Highsmith's original work and brings stunning new dimensions, making it a must-see for newcomers and long-time fans of the literary series. I’m sure this series will receive every award known to humankind. It’s that good.
I agree!! I watched Netflix "Ripley" and thought it was brilliant. Great review, Stacy!